Ariel Center for
Policy Research

A JOURNAL OF POLITICS AND THE ARTS

 

NATIV   ■   Volume Fourteen   ■   Number 2 (79)  ■  March 2001   ■  Ariel Center for Policy Research

 

SYNOPSIS

 


Regards from the GSS, Platoon D
(or: What if Yigal Amir had a Girlfriend Like Tinkerbell?)

Sarit Yalov

The movie, “A Time of Favor”, whose writer seemingly attempts to present “the conflict of conscience versus obligation”, is essentially a libelous indictment. Filled with caustic innuendoes about the activities of the “Temple Mount Faithful” on the one hand, and the character of Yigal Amir on the other, it constantly projects to viewers the sense that the religious settlers in Judea, Samaria and Gaza are capable of any evil.

“A Time of Favor” tells the story of a romantic triangle. One central character is Menahem – a handsome, knitted-kippa wearing paratroop platoon commander, who is dispatched by the rabbi of the “hesder” yeshiva in which he studied to establish a platoon of “hesder” yeshiva students. The second central character is Pini – a Torah genius, a close friend of Menahem and the rabbi’s favorite disciple. The third central character is Michal – Rabbi Meltzer’s rebellious daughter, designated for Pini but desirous of Menahem. The overwhelming influence of the rabbi’s teachings on Pini on the one hand, and his unrequited love for Michal on the other, lead him to attempt to bomb the Temple Mount, the mountain with the golden-domed mosque at its peak and the Western Wall at its foot – by utilizing those under Menahem’s command and means at his disposal. Menahem is suspected of belonging to a nationalist underground organization and successfully battles to prove his innocence. It seems that the writer’s inability to philosophically come to terms with the profound spiritual component of religious Zionism, left him with no alternative but to negate it totally. When he finally allows Rabbi Meltzer to interject a statement with even a hint of spirituality: “The Temple is not merely a building, the Temple Mount is not merely a place – it is an idea” – the statement is portrayed as cunning demagoguery which can only be countered by a sophisticated GSS officer with the ultimate retort: “One does not steal so many crates of ammunition for an idea.”

ACPR Contact usNativ Index